Vol 65, No 1 (2014)
Case report
Submitted: 2014-03-24
Accepted: 2014-03-24
Published online: 2014-03-24
Legal aspects of cruise medicine — can a non-US ship’s doctor be sued for malpractice in Florida?
Eilif Dahl
DOI: 10.5603/MH.2014.0003
·
IMH 2014;65(1):13-15.
Vol 65, No 1 (2014)
MARITIME MEDICINE Case report
Submitted: 2014-03-24
Accepted: 2014-03-24
Published online: 2014-03-24
Abstract
An English ship’s doctor treated a non-US female patient for abdominal discomfort on a foreign-flagged cruise ship off the coast of Haiti. In Mexico the patient underwent abdominal surgery, followed by complications, for which her lawyers wanted to take the ship’s doctor to court in Florida, USA. A trial court granted their wish, but this decision was reversed on appeal as the factors discussed were insufficient to establish Florida jurisdiction over the ship’s doctor. The decision is not about whether malpractice occurred; it is about limiting the possibility of taking the ship’s doctor to a court in a location preferred by the plaintiffs’ lawyers. The appeal court ruling is important for non-US doctors working as independent contractors on cruise vessels that visit US ports, and it will hopefully prevent some of the more frivolous law suits from being filed in the future.
Abstract
An English ship’s doctor treated a non-US female patient for abdominal discomfort on a foreign-flagged cruise ship off the coast of Haiti. In Mexico the patient underwent abdominal surgery, followed by complications, for which her lawyers wanted to take the ship’s doctor to court in Florida, USA. A trial court granted their wish, but this decision was reversed on appeal as the factors discussed were insufficient to establish Florida jurisdiction over the ship’s doctor. The decision is not about whether malpractice occurred; it is about limiting the possibility of taking the ship’s doctor to a court in a location preferred by the plaintiffs’ lawyers. The appeal court ruling is important for non-US doctors working as independent contractors on cruise vessels that visit US ports, and it will hopefully prevent some of the more frivolous law suits from being filed in the future.
Keywords
ship’s doctor, cruise ship, Florida jurisdiction, maritime medicine
Title
Legal aspects of cruise medicine — can a non-US ship’s doctor be sued for malpractice in Florida?
Journal
International Maritime Health
Issue
Vol 65, No 1 (2014)
Article type
Case report
Pages
13-15
Published online
2014-03-24
Page views
1133
Article views/downloads
2340
DOI
10.5603/MH.2014.0003
Bibliographic record
IMH 2014;65(1):13-15.
Keywords
ship’s doctor
cruise ship
Florida jurisdiction
maritime medicine