PRACE ORYGINALNE/ORIGINAL PAPERS
Comparison of the usefulness of post-ablative and post-operative thyroglobulin concentration measuring in prognostic assessment of patients with differentiated thyroid cancer
Porównanie przydatności oznaczeń stężenia tyreoglobuliny poablacyjnej i tyreoglobuliny pooperacyjnej w ocenie rokowania chorych ze zróżnicowanym rakiem tarczycy
Department of Endocrinology and Nuclear Medicine, Holycross Cancer Centre, Kielce, Poland
Klaudia Gadawska-Juszczyk M.D., Department of Endocrinology, Holycross Cancer Centre, Artwifiskiego St. 3, 25–734 Kielce, Poland, mobil phone: 509 272 150, fax: +48 41 367 42 81, e-mail: email@example.com, firstname.lastname@example.org
Introduction: Post-operative thyroglobulin (TgPO) is a recognised prognostic factor in patients following thyroidectomy due to differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC). However, its concentration is affected by thyroid remnants, which may diminish the prognostic value of TgPO. The aim of this paper is to assess the usefulness of stimulated post-ablative thyroglobulin (TgPA) measurements 6–9 months after 131I therapy, as a prognostic factor, and its possible advantage over TgPO determination.
Material and methods: The study involved 577 DTC patients treated in the Holycross Cancer Centre in the years 2000–2013. Exclusion criteria were: patients with no recommendation for 131I adjuvant therapy, positive thyroglobulin antibody titre, and initial distant metastases. On the basis of a ROC curve analysis, values of TgPO and TgPA concentrations were determined, which enable the most accurate identification of good prognosis. Calculating area under the curves (AUCs) allowed for comparison of the data.
Results: TgPO concentration ≤ 6.99 ng/mL, with 75.7% sensitivity and 94.7% specificity enables anticipation of remission of the disease. TgPA concentration ≤ 1.16 ng/mL under endogenous TSH stimulation with sensitivity of 91.1% and specificity of 94.7% allows anticipation of remission of the disease. TgPA concentration < 1.24 ng/mL under rh TSH stimulation with sensitivity of 95.4% and specificity of 95.0% enables anticipation of remission of the disease.
Conclusions: No differences in clinical usefulness of the assessment of TgPO and stimulated TgPA concentrations as indicators of good prognosis were found. However, TgPA allows anticipation of remission of the disease with higher sensitivity. It also appears that TgPA may be of particular prognostic importance in baseline high-risk patients (pT3-T4/N1). A sufficiently low TgPA concentration, demonstrating good response to 131I adjuvant therapy in these groups, is an indicator of improved prognosis. (Endokrynol Pol 2015; 66 (6): 486–494)
Key words: differentiated thyroid cancer; thyroglobulin; prognostic factors; disease remission
Wstęp: Tyreoglobulina pooperacyjna (TgPO) jest uznanym czynnikiem rokowniczym u pacjentów po tyreoidektomii z powodu raka zróżnicowanego tarczycy (DTC). Na jej stężenie wpływa jednak ilość pozostawionej tkanki tarczycowej, co może obniżać jej wartość jako wskaźnika prognostycznego. Celem pracy jest ocena przydatności oznaczeń stymulowanej tyreoglobuliny poablacyjnej (TgPA), ocenianej 6–9 miesięcy po leczeniu 131I, jako czynnika rokowniczego i jej ewentualna przewaga nad oznaczeniami TgPO.
Materiał i metody: Badaniem objęto 577 pacjentów z DTC leczonych w Świętokrzyskim Centrum Onkologii w latach 2000–2013. Wykluczono chorych niewymagających leczenia uzupełniającego 131I, chorych z dodatnim mianem przeciwciał przeciw tyreoglobulinie oraz z przerzutami odległymi obecnymi w chwili rozpoznania. Na podstawie analizy krzywych ROC, ustalono wartości stężeń TgPO i TgPA, które pozwalają najlepiej przewidywać dobre rokowanie. Ocena wielkości pól pod krzywymi (AUCs) umożliwiła porównanie obu parametrów.
Wyniki: Remisję stwierdzono u 93,2 % chorych, brak remisji u 6,8 % badanych. Stężenie TgPO ≤ 6,99 ng/ml z czułością 75,7% i swoistością 94,7 % pozwala przewidzieć remisję choroby. Stężenie TgPA ≤ 1,16 ng/ml na stymulacji endogennym TSH z czułością 91,1% i swoistością 94,7% pozwala przewidywać remisję choroby. Stężenie TgPA < 1,24 ng/ml na stymulacji rhTSH z czułością 95,4% i swoistością 95,0% pozwala przewidywać remisję choroby.
Wnioski: Nie wykazano różnic w przydatności klinicznej oceny stężenia TgPO i stymulowanej TgPA jako wskaźnika dobrej prognozy. Jednak TgPA przy stężeniu ≤ 1,24ng/ml pozwala z większą czułością przewidzieć remisję choroby. Wydaje się również, że TgPA może mieć szczególne znaczenie rokownicze u pacjentów z wyjściowo wysokim ryzykiem (pT3-T4/N1). Odpowiednio niskie stężenie TgPA, świadczące o dobrej odpowiedzi na leczenie uzupełniające 131I w tych grupach jest wskaźnikiem poprawy rokowania. (Endokrynol Pol 2015; 66 (6): 486–494)
Słowa kluczowe: zróżnicowany rak tarczycy; tyreoglobulina; czynniki rokownicze; remisja
Thyroglobulin (Tg) is a glycoprotein produced exclusively by the follicular cells of the thyroid. The follicular cells modified by the neoplastic process maintain the ability to produce thyroglobulin in most types of differentiated neoplasms .
Therefore, in patients following complete thyroidectomy and 131I ablative treatment due to differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC), Tg is used as a neoplastic marker to monitor the disease [2–6].
Differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) is a neoplasm characterised by good prognosis. Approximately 80% of patients recover after the first treatment. However, around 15% of patients are affected by local recurrence of the disease, and in 5–10% distant metastases occur. Most recurrences of the disease take place within the first five years; however, recurrences were also observed as late as after 45 years [7, 8]. Such reports necessitate life-long oncological monitoring of DTC patients.
Prognostic factors are still being sought that would enable the identification of patients with high risk of disease recurrence, allowing personalisation of the method of DTC management according to the patient’s risk group.
Recently, numerous publications have appeared indicating the usefulness of the assessment of thyroglobulin concentration following thyroid surgery (TgPO) as a prognostic marker. Makarewicz et al., using an analysis of 247 patients, demonstrated that TgPO > 38.1 ng/mL is strongly correlated with the presence of distant metastases (sensitivity — 0.57; specificity — 0.96) . The studies by Piccardo et al. established that in high-risk patients TgPO concentrations > 50 μ/L had the highest positive predictive value (PPV) — 97% for the presence of persistent disease, compared to factors such as age, feature T, N, G, or histological type of cancer . The cut-off point for TgPO concentration, indicating favourable prognosis, has not been arbitrarily established. It is believed that in patients with lower TgPO concentration the probability of persistent or recurring disease is reduced. It has been concluded in a few studies that TgPO concentrations < 10 ng/mL indicate good prognosis. Polachek et al. decided, based on observations of 420 patients, that this TgPO concentration has a negative predictive value (NPV) of 89% for persistent disease, with sensitivity and specificity of 73% . The same cut-off point for TgPO concentration, which enables one to anticipate a remission, has been determined by Piccardo et al. in low-risk  and high-risk  patients. In a two-year observation of 169 low-risk patients, they established that NPV for a recurrence of the disease was 100% with TgPO concentration < 10 ng/mL and undetectable Tg concentration during the suppressive treatment . In a group of 243 highrisk patients, NPV was 93% with TgPO concentration of <10 μg/L . Heemstra et al. advocate that TgPO concentrations < 27.5 μg/L enable anticipation of a favourable course of the disease (sensitivity — 87.9%, specificity — 90.3%; PPV for remission — 98%) . A study by Kim et al. demonstrated that patients with TgPO concentrations > 5.22 ng/mL are burdened with a higher risk of recurrence of the disease . Klubo-Gwiezdzinska et al. claimed TgPO < 5 ng/mL to have NPV = 100% in a study of 91 patients .
TgPO concentration values are affected by the presence of thyroid tissue remaining after surgery. It is estimated that 1 g of thyroid tissue causes an increase in Tg concentration of approximately 1 μg/L with normal TSH concentration, and by approximately 0.5 μg/L during TSH suppression. The fact may reduce the prognostic usefulness of TgPO .
It seems that the assessment of Tg concentration following ablative 131I treatment (TgPA) may demonstrate greater prognostic value. The aim of the work was to assess the usefulness of measuring Tg concentration under exogenous or endogenous TSH stimulation as a prognostic factor, and its possible advantage over the TgPO determination.
Material and methods
The study involved 1200 DTC patients treated in the Holycross Cancer Centre in the years 2000–2013. Patients with distant metastases at the diagnosis and those who did not require 131I adjuvant therapy were excluded from the study. Out of the remaining 661 patients, 85 were excluded due to the presence of thyroglobulin antibodies.
Eventually, the study involved 577 patients: 491 (85%) females and 86 (15%) males. The age median at the diagnosis was the same for both sexes, at 53 years (minimum-maximum age for women was 17–80 years, for men it was 23–76 years).
The dominant histological type was papillary carcinoma: 531 cases (92%), then follicular carcinoma — 33 cases (5.7%), insular carcinoma — 7 cases (1.2%), and oxyphil carcinoma — 6 cases (1%).
All patients underwent complete thyroidectomy with the intent to remove the central cervical compartment lymph nodes, and later they received adjuvant 131I treatment with 1100–3700 MBq activity, repeated according to indications.
Patients having pT1N0/Nx and pT2N0 stage were assigned for low 131-I activity (patients with Nx feature were considered as low-risk on the basis of undetectable TgPO and normal neck ultrasound). Patients who had pT2–4/Nx stage were assigned for high 131-I activity.
Table I presents in detail the distribution of patients by pTNM classification according to IUCC/AJCC TNM staging system 2010.
Table I. Characteristics of patients with remission and without remission
Tabela I. Charakterystyka pacjentów z remisją i chorobą przetrwałą
|Clinical factor||Patients in remission (n = 538)||Patients without remission (n = 39)||P value|
|Age (years) at the disease onset
|52 (42–60)||61 (50–69)||0.0021|
for Mann-Whitney test
|Female||466 (87%)||25 (64%)||0.0003|
for chi-square test
|Male||72 (13%)||14 (36%)|
|T1||275 (51%)||8 (21%)||0.0005|
for chi-square test1
|T2||74 (14%)||3 (8%)|
|T3||140 (26%)||22 (56%)|
|T4||25 (5%)||4 (10%)|
|Tx||24 (4%)||2 (5%)|
|N0||125 (23%)||5 (13%)||0.0001|
for chi-square test1
|N1||59 (11%)||14 (36%)|
|Nx||354 (66%)||20 (51%)|
|2.0 (0–148)||29.8 (4.29–300)||0.0001|
for Mann-Whitney test
|0.0 (0.0–20.5)||6.73 (0–105)||0.0001|
for Mann-Whitney test
|Papillary||500 (92.9%)||31 (79.4%)||0.0071|
|Oxyphil||5 (0.9%)||1 (2.6%)||0.8450|
|Follicular||30 (5.6%)||3 (7.7%)||0.8509|
|Insular||3 (0.6%)||4 (10.3%)||< 0.0001|
for chi-square test
Patients are under continuous observation with periodic clinical assessments. Median (Q1-Q3) for the follow-up period is 5 (2.0–9.0) years. At the moment of analysis, 538 patients (93.2%) are in remission, and 39 patients (6.8%) were diagnosed with persistent disease.
Remission was determined on the basis of normal results of ultrasound neck examination, absence of radiotracer uptake foci in whole body scintigraphy, undetectable Tg concentration during the treatment with suppressive dose of l-thyroxine, and TgPA concentration < 1 ng/mL on recombinant human thyroid-stimulating hormone (rh TSH) stimulation, or TgPA concentration < 2 ng/mL on endogenous thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) stimulation.
Ultrasound examination of the neck was performed with the use of devices with colour Doppler function: Siemens Versa pro and Hitachi EUB-6500, EUB-5500, with a linear transducer 7.5 MHz. Neck and whole body scintigraphy was performed with the use of a Symbia T2 gamma camera by Siemens, following administration of 131I diagnostic capsule of 80 MBq activity under endogenous TSH stimulation, and 200 MBq with rh TSH stimulation.
TgPO was assessed 3–6 weeks after the thyroidectomy, at qualification for the adjuvant 131I treatment, prior to implementation of substitute treatment with l-thyroxine. TgPA was assessed 6–9 months after the 131I treatment, under endogenous TSH stimulation or rh TSH stimulation (Thyrogen, Genzyme Corp., amp. 0.9 mg). One ampoule of Thyrogen i.m. was administered on two consecutive days, TgPA was measured on day 5 after the administration of the first dose. TgPO and TgPA were assessed with TSH ≥ 30 IU/mL ( range from ≥ 30 to > 100 IU/mL). During the l-thyroxine treatment, Tg was assessed every six months. Thyroglobulin was determined with the use of chemiluminescence — until 2007 on an Immulite 1 analyser by DPC, and since 2007 on an Immulite 2000 xpi Immunoassay System analyser by Siemens. The method’s analytical sensitivity was < 0.2 ng/mL.
For the measurable parameters tested the basic statistics were determined (mean, standard deviation, median, quartiles: first and third). For the qualitative characteristics, frequencies were determined. The Mann-Whitney test, Kruskal-Wallis test, and chi-square test were also used. Correlation analysis was used for pairs of measurable characteristics. ROC (Receiver Operating Characteristic) curve analysis was performed for TgPO and TgPA concentrations. Calculating the area under the curves (AUCs) allowed for comparison of the data. P-values were presented for the tests used. The value of p < 0.05 was adapted as denoting statistically significant relationship, difference, or correlation. The statistical analyses were performed with the use of MedCalc Statistical Software version 13.0.
The study was approved by the Local Bioethical Committee.
Among 577 study patients, in 538 (93.2%) disease remission was observed, and in the remaining 39 patients (6.8%) at the moment of analysis persistent disease was found.
Characteristics of patients with remission and with persistent disease are presented in Table I.
Patients with persistent disease or disease recurrence were older, more frequently they were males originally with a higher stage of clinical advancement T3-T4, and with lymph nodes metastases. The insular carcinoma type was associated with a higher risk of absence of remission. TgPO and TgPA concentrations were significantly higher in the patients without remission.
Detailed data of the patients without remission are presented in Table II.
Table II. Characteristics of patients without remission
Tabela II. Charakterystyka pacjentów bez remisji
|No.||Sex||Age||Histopatology||Absence of remission|
|3||F||63||ins.||Cerv. lymph nodes|
|20||F||69||pap.||( + )|
|23||F||43||pap.||( + )|
|29||F||49||pap.||Cerv. lymph nodes|
|62||M||58||pap.||Cerv. lymph nodes|
|73||F||71||oxy.||( + )|
|84||F||57||pap.||( + )|
|109||F||62||pap.||( + )|
|124||F||29||pap.||( + )|
|125||F||79||fol.||( + )|
|137||F||32||pap.||Cerv. lymph nodes|
|141||M||66||pap.||( + )|
|178||F||55||pap.||( + )|
|186||F||71||ins.||Cerv. lymph nodes|
|195||M||44||pap.||( + )|
|199||M||64||pap.||Cerv. lymph nodes|
|294||M||61||pap.||( + )|
|307||F||65||pap.||Cerv. lymph nodes|
|317||F||61||pap.||( + )|
|323||F||73||pap.||Cerv. lymph nodes|
|327||F||56||pap.||( + )|
|348||F||70||pap.||Cerv. lymph nodes|
|410||F||50||pap.||( + )|
|428||F||53||pap.||( + )|
|435||M||75||pap.||( + )|
|445||F||40||fol.||( + )|
|461||M||29||pap.||( + )|
|463||M||55||pap.||( + )|
|467||M||34||pap.||Cerv. lymph nodes|
|478||M||64||pap.||( + )|
|520||F||27||pap.||( + )|
|540||M||72||fol.||( + )|
|550||F||72||pap.||Cerv. lymph nodes|
|558||F||53||pap.||( + )|
|562||F||75||pap.||( + )|
Table II. Characteristics of patients without remission cont.
Tabela II. Charakterystyka pacjentów bez remisji cd.
|No.||Sex||Age||Diagnostic method||Time to recurrence||TgPA [ng/mL]|
|109||F||62||17 months||< 0.2|
|334||F||62||PET/CT||10 years||< 0.2|
The analysis of TgPO concentration relationships is presented in Table III.
Table III. Analysis of relationships between mean or median TgPO concentrations and sex, histological type of the cancer, and TN feature
Tabela III. Analiza zależności średniego stężenia oraz mediany stężenia TgPO w stosunku do płci, typu histologicznego raka i cechy TN
|Clinical factor||Values of clinical factors||TgPO [ng/mL]|
|Number of patients||Mean (SD)|
|Histological type||Papillary carcinoma||531||8.5 (20.0)|
|Follicular carcinoma||33||20.1 (41.4)|
|Insular carcinoma||7||111.7 (135.3)|
|Oxyphil carcinoma||6||33.60 (66.7)|
|Number of patients||Mean (SD)||Median (Q1–Q3)||Number of patients||Mean (SD)||Median (Q1–Q3)|
|T1||68||7.5 (15.2)||1.4 (0.5–7.1)||23||6.8 (7.2)||5.6 (1.1–8.9)|
|T2||11||12.1 (26.1)||2.4 (0.5–10.8)||9||16.7 (21.3)||7.2 (0.5–33.5)|
|T3||45||3.9 (6.1)||2.1 (0.2–6.2)||34||18.6 (52.5)||2.3 (0.3–17.5)|
|T4||5||7.8 (13.2)||0.4 (0.3–13.3)||6||17.9 (27.8)||9.1 (1–14.5)|
Table III. Analysis of relationships between mean or median TgPO concentrations and sex, histological type of the cancer, and TN feature cont.
Tabela III. Analiza zależności średniego stężenia oraz mediany stężenia TgPO w stosunku do płci, typu histologicznego raka i cechy TN cd.
|Clinical factor||Values of clinical factors||TgPO [ng/mL]||p value1|
|Sex||F||2.00 (0–7.5)||< 0.0001|
|Histological type||Papillary carcinoma||2.2 (0.3–7.5)||0.00042|
|Follicular carcinoma||8.4 (1.8–16.2)|
|Insular carcinoma||29.8 (5.4–254.8)|
|Oxyphil carcinoma||2.0 (2–27.6)|
|Number of patients||Mean (SD)||Median (Q1–Q3)|
|T1||192||7.7 (17.5)||2.22 (0–8.2)||0.38383|
|T2||57||3.8 (5.6)||1.9 (0–5.2)||0.17953|
|T3||83||19.4 (48.9)||3.1 (0.8–13.5)||0.09253|
|T4||18||15.3 (25.2)||0.6 (0–28.5)||0.36683|
It was demonstrated that TgPO concentration depended on the sex of patients, and it was higher in males, as well as on the histological cancer type — the highest values were obtained in insular carcinoma. However, no statistically significant relationship was found between TgPO concentration and age at the onset of the disease, clinical advancement of the cancer, and lymph nodes condition.
Considering further course of the disease, on the basis of ROC curve analysis, we established that TgPO concentration < 6.99 ng/mL, with 75.7% sensitivity and specificity of 94.7% enabled us to anticipate remission of the disease (p < 0.001). This is shown in Figure 1.
Among 410 patients with TgPO < 6.99 ng/mL, the absence of remission was observed in three patients, whereas out of 167 patients with Tg over this threshold remission was absent in 36 patients (p < 0.0001).
TgPA was assessed under endogenous thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) stimulation in 254 patients, and under recombinant human thyroid-stimulating hormone (rh TSH) stimulation in 323 patients.
Mean (SD) TgPA concentration under endogenous TSH stimulation was 1.98 (9.62) ng/mL. Mean (SD) TgPA concentration under rh TSH stimulation was 1.57 (8.15) ng/mL. The observed difference was statistically nonsignificant. Median stimulated TgPA concentrations in both groups were zero.
The analysis of TgPA concentration relationships is presented in Table IV.
Table IV. Analysis of relationships between mean and median stimulated TgPA concentrations (together for endogenous TSH and rh TSH) and sex, histological type of the cancer, and TN feature
Tabela IV. Analiza zależności średniego stężenia oraz mediany stężenia stymulowanej TgPA (łącznie dla endogennego TSH i rh TSH) w stosunku do płci, typu histologicznego raka, cechy TN
|Clinical factor||Values of clinical factors||TgPO [ng/mL]|
|Number of patients||Mean (SD)|
|Histological type||Papillary carcinoma||531||1.3 (7.5)|
|Follicular carcinoma||33||1.6 (4.3)|
|Insular carcinoma||7||25.3 (33.6)|
|Oxyphil carcinoma||6||10.4 (25.1)|
|Number of patients||Mean (SD)||Median (Q1–Q3)||Number of patients||Mean (SD)||Median (Q1–Q3)|
|T1||68||0.5 (2.3)||0 (0–0)||23||1.9 (4.5)||0 (0–1.0)|
|T2||11||0.6 (1.1)||0 (0–9)||9||20.7 (32.9)||0.6 (0–42.1)|
|T3||45||0.5 (1.9)||0 (0–0)||34||3.2 (8.7)||0 (0–1.6)|
|T4||5||0.4 (0.5)||0 (0–9)||6||0.5 (0.8)||0 (0–1.3)|
Table IV. Analysis of relationships between mean and median stimulated TgPA concentrations (together for endogenous TSH and rh TSH) and sex, histological type of the cancer, and TN feature cont.
Tabela IV. Analiza zależności średniego stężenia oraz mediany stężenia stymulowanej TgPA (łącznie dla endogennego TSH i rh TSH) w stosunku do płci, typu histologicznego raka, cechy TN cd.
|Clinical factor||Values of clinical factors||TgPO [ng/mL]||p value1|
|Histological type||Papillary carcinoma||0 (0–0.2)||0.00212|
|Follicular carcinoma||0 (0–1.3)|
|Insular carcinoma||1.9 (0.2–56.3)|
|Oxyphil carcinoma||0 (0–0.5)|
|Number of patients||Mean (SD)||Median (Q1–Q3)|
|T1||192||0.6 (3.3)||0 (0–0)||0.04483|
|T2||57||0.5 (1.9)||0 (0–0)||0.85053|
|T3||83||4.4 (16.1)||0 (0–1.0)||0.04393|
|T4||18||1.8 (6.0)||0 (0–0.5)||0.32743|
It was demonstrated that stimulated TgPA concentration depended on the sex of patients and was higher in males. No statistically significant relationship was found between stimulated TgPA concentrations and age at the disease onset.
The median for papillary carcinoma, follicular carcinoma, and oxyphil carcinoma was zero, and for insular carcinoma it was 1.91 ng/mL. A statistically significant difference was observed in median TgPA concentrations (calculated in total for endogenous TSH and rh TSH stimulation) between individual histological types of carcinoma (papillary and insular carcinoma). In T1 and T3 groups a statistically significant relationship between TgPA and N1/N0 feature was observed. This was probably due to a larger number of patients in these groups compared to groups T2 and T4.
On the basis of ROC curve analysis we established that TgPA concentration ≤ 1.16 ng/mL under endogenous TSH stimulation with a sensitivity of 91.1% and specificity of 94.7% enabled us to anticipate remission of the disease. (p < 0.001). This is shown in Figure 2.
Among 215 patients with TgPA ≤ 1.16 ng/mL for endogenous TSH, remission did not occur in one patient, whereas out of 39 patients with TgPA > 1.16 ng/mL the absence of remission was observed in 18 patients (p < 0.0001). TgPA concentration ≤ 1.24 ng/mL under rh TSH stimulation with sensitivity of 95.4% and specificity of 95.0% enabled us to anticipate remission of the disease (p < 0.001). This is shown in Figure 3.
Among 290 patients with TgPA concentration under rh TSH stimulation ≤ 1.24 ng/mL, remission did not occur in one patient, whereas out of 33 patients with concentration > 1.24 ng/mL the absence of remission was observed in 19 patients (p < 0.0001).
The difference between AUCs ( TgPO vs. TgPA) was 0.0255 (p = 0.3133), which means the both parameters are of the same prognostic value. However, compared to TgPO, TgPA concentration demonstrates significantly higher sensitivity: 95.4% for rh TSH stimulation and 91.1% for endogenous TSH stimulation (vs. 75.7% for TgPO) with at least the same specificity as TgPO in anticipating the disease remission — as shown in Table V.
Table V. Comparison of sensitivity and specificity of TgPO and TgPA in predicting remission. Tg criteria for remission established on the basis of ROC curve analysis
Tabela V. Porównanie czułości i swoistości TgPO i TgPA w odniesieniu do remisji. Punkt odcięcia stężenia Tg ustalony w oparciu o analizę krzywych ROC
|Tg||Sensitivity (%)||Specificity (%)||Criterion [ng/mL]|
|TgPA under endogenous TSH stimulation||91.1||94.7||< 1.16|
|TgPA under rhTSH stimulation||95.4||95.0||< 1.24|
Our study involved 577 patients with DTC. Remission was observed in 93.2% of patients, and absence of remission in 6.8% of patients.
A similarly low percentage of patients with disease recurrence (9%) was reported by Toubeau et al. in a study on 212 patients, after the patients with distant metastases present at the moment of diagnosis had been excluded from the observation .
The median follow-up period was five years, i.e. the time when the risk of thyroid cancer recurrence is highest (18), although the disease may recur at any moment in the patient’s life [2, 8]. TgPO concentration is a prognostic factor which enables early anticipation of the course of the disease. The cut-off point for TgPO concentration, indicating favourable prognosis, has not been arbitrarily established. Values described in the literature range from ≤ 10 to ≤ 50 ng/mL.
In our study, we established, on the basis of ROC curve analysis, that TgPO concentration ≤ 6.99 ng/mL enabled us to anticipate remission of the disease with the highest sensitivity and specificity. However, TgPO determination has its limitations. First, its concentration is affected by the thyroid tissue remaining after thyroidectomy. Webb et al., on the basis of a meta-analysis of nearly 4000 DTC patients, determined that PPV for the disease recurrence with TgPO concentration > 10 ng/mL is only 47%, which they associated primarily with the thyroid tissue remaining after the surgery .
Moreover, low TgPO concentration does not always guarantee favourable prognosis. Usually, undetectable TgPO concentration indicates completeness of the surgical procedure. However, there are reports of patients who, despite undetectable TgPO (in the absence of Tg antibodies), developed a recurrence or persistent disease. In a study by Phan HT et al. such a course of the disease was observed in 8.5% (8/94) of patients with undetectable TgPO concentration. During a follow-up, in a few patients a detectable Tg concentration or Tg antibodies occurred. The authors explain it not only by imperfect methodology of Tg determination, but also by possible changes in the neoplasm properties. In their opinion, the frequency of the disease recurrences is the same in the group of patients with detectable and undetectable TgPO, and they emphasise the usefulness of Tg and Tg antibodies determination in the monitoring of DTC patients, despite an undetectable TgPO [20, 21].
Therefore, we decided to assess the usefulness of stimulated TgPA determination as a prognostic factor, and demonstrate its possible advantage over TgPO measurements.
It is suggested that the cut-off point for rh TSH-stimulated TgPA should be lower compared to endogenous TSH-stimulated TgPA , because higher sensitivity and specificity are ascribed to TgPA stimulated by endogenous TSH. It is associated with the fact that Tg concentration increases together with prolonged time of TSH stimulation, and the time is longer in the case of hypothyroidism caused by endogenous TSH than in the case of rh TSH without inducing hypothyroidism [16, 22].
In a meta-analysis comprising over 9000 patients, Eustatia-Rutten C. F et al. established the highest sensitivity and specificity of TgPA stimulated with endogenous TSH, comparable sensitivity but lower specificity of TgPA stimulated with rh TSH, and in patients who did not undergo ablation the Tg specificity was significantly lower .
However, we believe that the diagnostic accuracy of both measurements is comparable [24–28].
In the results obtained in our study, the stimulated TgPA concentration which best correlated with the disease remission did not depend on the type of TSH stimulation, and it was ≤ 1.24 ng/mL for rh TSH and ≤ 1.16 ng/mL for endogenous TSH. Compared to TgPO, TgPA concentration demonstrates significantly higher sensitivity: 95.4% for rh TSH stimulation and 91.1% for endogenous TSH stimulation (vs. 75.7% for TgPO) with at least the same specificity as TgPO in anticipating the disease remission. TgPA concentration is, therefore, as equally a significant prognostic factor as TgPO concentration .
In a study based on an analysis of 715 patients with median follow-up of 6.2 years, Brassard M. et al. arrived at a very similar cut-off point for TgPA (stimulated with endogenous or rh TSH) = 1.4 ng/mL, indicating favourable prognosis with the sensitivity of 78%, specificity of 90%, and NPV of 99% .
On the basis of a study involving 212 patients with median follow-up of five years, Toubeau et al. evaluated TgPA to be the most important (similarly to lymph node invasion) prognostic factor in DTC (with the value of ≤ 10 ng/mL). TgPO (≤ 30 ng/mL) was also reliable, although less significant .
Also Pelttari et al. in their 16-year observation of 495 low-risk patients (TNM I-II) emphasise the importance of TgPA and N1 feature as the only independent predictors of the disease recurrence .
A study by Molinaro et al. established that in patients with TgPA < 5.4 ng/mL, with time a spontaneous recovery occurred, despite a non-optimal response to 131I ablative treatment. Simultaneously, the authors emphasised the possibly important significance of TgPA determination for prognosis .
Moreover, in our study we were researching the relationship between Tg concentration and the histopathological type of thyroid cancer. We observed statistically significantly higher TgPO concentrations in the follicular carcinoma than in the papillary carcinoma. Insular carcinoma was distinguished by a high TgPO concentration, as this type of cancer, despite a small number of patients , obtained the highest values and statistically significantly differed in that respect from papillary carcinoma. TgPA was also statistically significantly different between the papillary and insular carcinomas.
Among seven patients with insular carcinoma there were five females and two males. Remission was achieved in three female patients with pT2N0/pT2Nx advancement stage and a maximum TgPO concentration of 7.48 ng/mL, and TgPA concentrations undetectable in two cases and equal to 0.60 ng/mL in one patient. The patients who did not achieve remission included two males and two females with baseline advancement stages pT3 and pT2N1. In one case TgPO was 29 ng/mL, and in the remaining cases — 149, 290, and > 300 ng/mL (TgPA of 32.6; 1.91; 64.2; 78 ng/mL, respectively). Three patients developed metastases to the lungs, and in one patient metastases to the paratracheal lymph nodes were identified on the basis of a PET examination.
Remission did not occur in the patients who did not demonstrate sufficient response to the 131I treatment, and the TgPA concentration — except for one patient (TgPA — 1.91 ng/mL) in whom it still remained significantly increased.
In our study we also assessed the relationship between TgPO or TgPA and the pTN stage. We did not observe a statistically significant difference in TgPO between the high-risk and low-risk groups, which is probably due to a large percentage of patients with the Nx feature. However, we observed higher TgPA concentrations in the patients with invaded lymph nodes in the T1 and T3 groups. The absence of a similar observation in the T2 and T4 groups is probably caused by a lower number of patients in these groups, as well as by the frequent presence of the Nx feature.
However, it appears that TgPA may be of particular prognostic importance in baseline high-risk patients (pT3-T4/N1). Sufficiently low TgPA concentration, demonstrating good response to 131I adjuvant therapy in these groups, is an indicator of improved prognosis. Prognosis becomes comparable to that assumed for the patients with lower advancement stage at the baseline (pT1-T2) .
On the basis of the analysis of patients with insular carcinoma, it also seems that the concentration of stimulated TgPA in DTC cases with biologically higher malignancy potential, and maintained ability to produce Tg, may be an indicator of the course of the disease.
No differences in clinical usefulness of the assessment of TgPO and stimulated TgPA concentrations as indicators of good prognosis were found. However, stimulated TgPA at a concentration ≤ 1.24 ng/mL enabled us to anticipate remission of the disease with significantly higher sensitivity than TgPO. No significant difference in TgPA concentrations depending on the type of stimulation (endogenous TSH and rh TSH) was observed.
It seems that stimulated TgPA may demonstrate a higher diagnostic value than TgPO in patients with more advanced stages of DTC (pT3-T4), as well as in histologically less differentiated cancers (insular carcinoma), i.e. cancers with higher malignancy potential and maintained ability to produce Tg. A sufficiently low concentration of stimulated TgPA indicates a good response to the 131I ablative treatment, and a better prognosis. However, this still needs to be determined unambiguously in further investigation.
- Schlumberger M, Baudin E. Serum thyroglobulin determination in the follow-up of patients with differentiated thyroid carcinoma. Eur J Endocrinol 1998; 138: 249–252.
- Mazzaferri EL, Kloos RT Current approaches to primary therapy for papillary and follicular thyroid cancer J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2001; 86: 1447–1463.
- Torrens JI, Burch HB. Serum thyroglobulin measurement: utility in clinical practice. Endocrinol Metab Clin North Am 2001; 30: 429–467.
- Pacini F, Molinaro E, Castagna MG et al. Recombinant human thyrotropin-stimulated serum thyroglobulin combined with neck ultrasonography has the highest sensitivity in monitoring differentiated thyroid carcinoma. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2003; 88: 3668–3673.
- Torlontano M, Crocetti U, Augello G et al. Comparative evaluation of recombinant human thyrotropin-stimulated thyroglobulin levels, 131I whole-body scintigraphy, and neck ultrasonography in the follow-up of patients with papillary thyroid microcarcinoma who have not undergone radioiodine therapy. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2006; 91: 60–63.
- Makarewicz J, Lewiński A. Prognostic factors in patients with differentiated thyroid carcinoma. Postepy Hig Med Dosw (Online) 2004; 58: 514–521.
- Mazzaferri EL; Kloos RT. Current approaches to primary therapy for papillary and follicular thyroid cancer. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2001; 86: 1447–1463.
- Leung AM, Dave S, Lee SL et al. Factors determining the persistence or recurrence of well-differentiated thyroid cancer treated by thyroidectomy and/or radioiodine in the Boston, Massachusetts area: A retrospective chart review. Thyroid Res 2011; 4: 9.
- Makarewicz J, Adamczewski Z, Knapska-Kucharska M et al. An evaluation of the value of first thyroglobulin determination in the diagnostics of metastases immediately following differentiated thyroid carcinoma surgery. Endokynol Pol 2006; 57: 370–373.
- Piccardo A, Arecco F, Puntoni M et al. Focus on high-risk DTC patients: high postoperative serum thyroglobulin level is a strong predictor of disease persistence and is associated to progression-free survival and overall survival. Clin Nucl Med 2013; 38: 18–24.
- Polachek A, Hirsch D, Tzvetov G et al. Prognostic value of post-thyroidectomy thyroglobulin levels in patients with differentiated thyroid cancer. J Endocrinol Invest 2011; 34: 855–860.
- Piccardo A, Arecco F, Morbelli S et al. Low thyroglobulin concentrations after thyroidectomy increase the prognostic value of undetectable thyroglobulin levels on levo-thyroxine suppressive treatment in low-risk differentiated thyroid cancer. J Endocrinol Invest 2010; 33: 83–87.
- Heemstra KA, Liu YY, Stokkel M et al. Serum thyroglobulin concentrations predict disease free remission and death in differentiated thyroid carcinoma. Clin Endocrinol (Oxf) 2007; 66: 58–64.
- Kim MH, Ko SH, Bae JS et al. Combination of initial stimulation thyroglobulins and staging system by revised ATA guidelines can elaborately discriminate prognosis of patients with differentiated thyroid carcinoma after high-dose remnant ablation. Clin Nucl Med 2012; 37: 1069–1074.
- Kłubo-Gwieździńska J, Junik R. The early treatment results of well differentiated thyroid cancer and its dependence on chosen factors. Endokrynol Pol 2008; 59: 123–130.
- Baloch Z, Carayon P Conte-Devolx B et al. Laboratory medicine practice guidelines. Laboratory support for the diagnosis and monitoring of thyroid disease. Thyroid 2003; 13: 3–126.
- Toubeau M, Touzery C, Arveux P et al. Predictive value for disease progression of serum thyroglobulin levels measured in the postoperative period and after (131)I ablation therapy in patients with differentiated thyroid cancer. J Nucl Med 2004; 45: 988–994.
- Durante C, Montesano T, Torlontano M et al. Papillary thyroid cancer: time course of recurrences during postsurgery surveillance. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2013; 98: 636–642.
- Webb RC, Howard RS, Stojadinovic A et al. The utility of serum thyroglobulin measurement at the time of remnant ablation for predicting disease-free status in patients with differentiated thyroid cancer: a meta-analysis involving 3947 patients. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2012; 97: 2754–2763.
- Phan HT, Jager PL, van der Wal JE et al. The follow-up of patients with differentiated thyroid cancer and undetectable thyroglobulin (Tg) and Tg antibodies during ablation. Eur J Endocrinol 2008; 158: 77–83.
- Spencer CA, Bergoglio LM, Kazarosyan M et al. Clinical impact of thyroglobulin (Tg) and Tg autoantibody method differences on the management of patients with differentiated thyroid carcinomas. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2005; 90: 5566–5575.
- Ladenson PW, Braverman LE, Mazzaferri EL et al. Comparison of administration of recombinant human thyrotropin with withdrawal of thyroid hormone for radioactive iodine scanning in patients with thyroid carcinoma. N Engl J Med 1997; 337: 888–896.
- Eustatia-Rutten CF, Smit JW, Romijn JA et al. Diagnostic value of serum thyroglobulin measurements in the follow-up of differentiated thyroid carcinoma, a structured meta-analysis. Clin Endocrinol 2004; 61: 61–74.
- Haugen BR, Pacini F, Reiners C et al. A comparison of recombinant human thyrotropin and thyroid hormone withdrawal for the detection of thyroid remnant or cancer. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 1999; 84: 3877–3885.
- Pacini F, Molinaro E, Lippi F et al. Prediction of disease status by recombinant human TSH-stimulated serum Tg in the postsurgical follow-up of differentiated thyroid carcinoma. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2001; 86: 5686–5690.
- Robbins RJ, Tuttle RM, Sharaf RN et al. Preparation by recombinant human thyrotropin or thyroid hormone withdrawal are comparable for the detection of residual differentiated thyroid carcinoma. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2001; 86: 619–625.
- Schlumberger M, Pacini F, Wiersinga WM et al. Follow-up and management of differentiated thyroid carcinoma: a European perspective in clinical practice. Eur J Endocrinol 2004; 151: 539–548.
- Mazzaferri EL, Robbins RJ, Spencer CA et al. A consensus report of the role of serum thyroglobulin as a monitoring method for low-risk patients with papillary thyroid carcinoma. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2003; 88: 1433–1441.
- Brassard M, Borget I, Edet-Sanson A et al. Long-term follow-up of patients with papillary and follicular thyroid cancer: a prospective study on 715 patients. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2011; 96: 1352–1359.
- Pelttari H, Välimäki MJ, Löyttyniemi E et al. Post-ablative serum thyroglobulin is an independent predictor of recurrence in low-risk differentiated thyroid carcinoma: a 16-year follow-up study. Eur J Endocrinol 2010; 163: 757–763.
- Molinaro E, Giani C, Agate L et al. Patients with differentiated thyroid cancer who underwent radioiodine thyroid remnant ablation with low-activity 131I after either recombinant human TSH or thyroid hormone therapy withdrawal showed the same outcome after a 10-year follow-up. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2013; 98: 2693–2700.